Zebra finches form life-long relationships, usually with members of the opposite sex. But a study published in the journal Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology found that male birds raised together form bonds with each other that are just as strong.
Sixteen male finches were raised to adulthood together. Upon reaching maturity, the males coupled up and showed signs of affection, like singing, preening and nuzzling beaks. When females were then introduced to the finches' cage, five of the eight male-male pairs stayed together and ignored the females.
“Relationships in animals can be more complicated than just a male and a female who meet and reproduce, even in birds,” said lead researcher Julie Elie of the University of California Berkeley in an interview with the BBC.
The researchers did not report any sexual activity between the paired males, only that they formed cooperative bonds. This suggested to the researchers that the survival advantages of having a pair bond can be more complex than simply having a reproductive partner.
"A pair-bond in socially monogamous species represents a cooperative partnership that may give advantages for survival," said Elie. "Finding a social partner, whatever its sex, could be a priority."
Although some have reported this as evidence of homosexuality in the animal kingdom, the lack of any observed sexual behavior means there is an important piece missing from that argument. Just because males are affectionate to each other and live together doesn't mean their “bro-mance” is homosexual.
Same sex pair bonds have been observed in birds before. Elie noted the case of female albatross, who will bond with another female, then mate with a male from another pair bond in order to raise a chick with her female partner.
"Female partners copulate with a paired male then rear the young together," Elie said.
In the zebra finch study, females were not raised together, so it is unknown if female finches will form pair bonds as well.
The famous relationship of two male penguins, Roy and Silo, at Manhattan's Central Park Zoo is another example of same-sex pair bonding in birds. The two male chinstrap penguins formed such a strong bond that they were even able to incubate and hatch a fertilized egg that a keeper placed in their nest.
In situations like these, humans are quick to put their own sexual definitions on animals. But it is important to remember that our own sexual definitions of hetero- vs. homosexual are set by our cultures, and the labels we put on each other and on animals are based in our culture as well. Cultural sterotypes in some human societies about male-male affection may make people inclined to label affection between male animals as evidence of homosexuality.
Putting our labels on animal behaviors runs the risk of anthropomorphic interpretation, or seeing human characteristics in animal behaviors.
Let me be the first to say, that I think this is normal, and okay. I mean many people growing up know that they had a best friend, either in school or there regular life. We had a great special bond with that person, such as holding hands, or dressing alike. Something along those majorities. This I believe is the same scenario. So what, birds have a best friend with same sex, I mean don't we all? As long as no sexual relations-- we're all good.
ReplyDeleteAWW this is so cute! A bird BROMANCE. How adorable. Its like when guys say "Bros before h0es" lol. This is pretty cool that even animals do this. Makes you wonder if they're really as dumb as we think they are compared to humans.
ReplyDeleteI find this both cute and kind of weird. It's cool that the males can form such strong bonds with each other like they are brothers, but its also weird that they act like lovers. Part of me wonders why they do this and why they reject the females when introduced to them. I have nothing against homosexual people, same as animals. As long as they are happy that's all that should matter. But, I understand where people are coming from when they say that humans are quick to put their own sexual definitions on the homosexual birds. Humans always judge people each other and other things/animals based off of stereotypes, and not everyone will agree with everyone else. Like I said though, I think that the whole thing with the two male birds acting like homosexual lovers is cute, but it is also a bit strange because I didn't know animals acted like this.
ReplyDeleteI love bromances! I think it's funny. I ship same sex relationships, whether it's humans or animals. I even ship and living or non living things.. If that's possible. But it's also kind of weird to think about. It's a good thing i'm a weird person.
ReplyDeleteI think this is a great example of animals helping each other. I really dont see any issues with it but I think it is kind of funny that these birds are forming relationships that you would normally only think you see in people.
ReplyDeleteI am shocked about birds forming long term relationships. I think it is so cute that there are bromances. I also think that it is very smart. It could be very helpful. It is weird seeing similarities in bird and human relationships.
ReplyDeleteI think of this is kind of weird. I dont think the birds are homosexual. They are birds not humans.
ReplyDeleteHomosexuality in birds and other species of animals? I think it could be possible but it's not scientifically proven yet. If it's proven, then good for them and for science. We all would learn something new but if not, then they're just 2 friends who hang out and care for eachother. Its like having another sibling in my eyes. You care for that sibling and protect it at all cost. Interesting article
ReplyDeleteI don't see how people could use this for a homosexuality argument. It's seems like a friendship bond more than a romantic relationship. It kind of reminds me of those friends that claim each other as siblings.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure that the relatinship between the birds is necessarily homosexual. Birds and other species often times pair up when it comes to survival needs. I think this is another case very similar. If these finches were only around one another they could form a bond. I would think that there could be homosexual birds but when they're forced to be together it isn't much of an experiment. Probably these relatiomships were more so brotherly or sisterly.
ReplyDeleteI believe that humans and birds should not be compared when discussing homosexuality arguments that is just weird. the birds bond seems to be more of a brotherly bond not a love connection. Zebra birds have life span to 4 to 9 years, do you really think they have time to do something out of their nature?
ReplyDeleteI find it interesting that birds in the animal kingdom pair up and make a bond with the same sex. This article just proves how complex the animal kingdom is. When was this study conducted? Have they tried this with bigger organisms in the animal kingdom?
ReplyDeleteThis is not surprising at all. If humans can form long time bonds with the same sex why do people think it's weird for birds to? Just because they aren't humans it doesn't mean that all animals have the soul purpose for reproduceing and then dying. I wonder if the female's would do the same.
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting that birds can make long term Relationships. But I'm not very surprised. There have been other species that have done this also.
ReplyDeleteI think this a great example for how animals interact with each other. Its kind of weird because I never imagined a male on male animal relationship, I always thought it was a human thing. I think its cool to learn more about the world's animals and how they interact with each other. Do ALL organisms do the same sex relationship?
ReplyDeleteI think this is pretty cool. I love that the scientists feel as if we shouldn't label the animals as hetero or homosexual. Same should go for humans. I was also shocked that the birds actually formed long lasting relationships.
ReplyDeleteI always thought about whether animals could create long term relationships and bonds like humans do with eachother, I think it is really cool and interesting that they do. But, at the same time it is weird that they automatically do same sex relationships. I figured they would do male female relationships before same sex relationships. I would like to know what other animals form long term relationships.
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that this birds were just "best friends" concerting the lack of current affection. I always thought of some animals to not have feelings and just thought about reproducing, then going on with their lives. I find this interesting because I never thought birds could have feelings. Also these males might just be comfortable around each other and not around the females.
ReplyDeleteAwww i think this is the cutest thing ever. I love the fact that it calls their relationship a "bro-mance". I think it's clever how five of the eight males,stayed together and ignored the females. This a very unique topic . It proves that every living thing has it's own feelings & thoughts, from humans to the smaller creatures .
ReplyDeleteI think this experiment is stupid. But is also pretty cool. It isn't as important to find a mate but to find a bird that is more compatable for it. They are looking for a bird that they want to survive with and they meet each others guidelines. also kind of weird how the male cares for the kids.
ReplyDeleteI find this pretty interesting. I mean, considering that male-female relations are most thought of in nature, it is certainly intriguing to see what other forms of relationships can be formed to survive. This really shakes up many of the preconceived notions about animal kingdom. Now I just want to sit back and see how this affects future ecological studies into bird behavior.
ReplyDeleteI think it is cool how tendencies such as these are found in human culture today. If you go a plays with many young people, such as the lunch room, you typically see males grouped with males and females grouped with other females with a few mixed groups. I can also see where relationships such as these can come in handy for these birds.
ReplyDeleteThis somewhat proves that gay marriage should be excepted in today society. Even BIRDS are doing it. As long as the birds are succeeding at staying alive, what sex you are forming a bond with should not matter.
ReplyDelete